My wife had a filet, Oscar style, with asparagus, crab meat and bearnaise sauce....I had orange roughy. The main room is noisy which makes this not a romantic place if that's what you intend. As soon as waitress came and we ordered Dt Coke and Hot tea, she truly couldn't get us out of there fast enough. Colony House provides a great dining get-away. Everything from the food to the service is spot on. variety of options but is not overwhelming. A generous selection of well-prepared meals is offered and graciously served by pleasant waitresses in Colonial dresses in a homelike atmosphere enhanced by many early American antique furnishings. Another person had the Salmon, he liked it and my husband had the lamb chops which he said he had much better elsewhere. Only ate one piece. JF) • Trevor, Wisconsin 53179 • Phone : (262) 862-2076 • Fax : (262) 862-1533 This famous small country restaurant is located at the junction of two country roads bordering rich Wisconsin farmlands and the neat Rock Lake community of homes one half mile south of Trevor, Wisconsin. Johnny's Chop House has 5 seatings Mother's Day $29.95 Adults see their Facebook page. Waitress asked if I wanted fries or potato pancakes and I asked if I could get a salad. We thank you for your continued support. Haven’t been back since. Colony House Restaurant; Menu Menu for Colony House Restaurant All entrees include:Soup; Your Choice of Caesar, Spinach, or Tossed Salad; Your Choice of Baked Potato, Twice Baked Potato, French Fries, Rice, or Pasta; and Honey Glazed Carrots on Request. Two at our table has the small filets with only one being done as requested. My husband had the prime rib and shrimp combo and also enjoyed it very much. Maintaining guest health is of utmost importance to us. Colony House Restaurant: Love the Colony House - See 155 traveller reviews, 26 candid photos, and great deals for Trevor, WI, at Tripadvisor. I had the Oscars Filet Mignon love the sauce wife had Stuffed Flounder very moist she said our sons had New York Strip cooked perfectly and the other had...a Stuffed Filet. I always tip based on what something cost before any discount. Our food came right away...Greasy thick battered perch, not what I expected. the prices are fair, and even the twin lobster tails at market aren't outrageous. Continue your visit to www.tripadvisor.co.uk, 25811 119th St Highway JF, Trevor, WI 53179-9670. Fresh cold boiled jumbo shrimp served with homemade cocktail sauce, Escargot, Brie cheese, garlic and butter all baked under a golden puff pastry, Shrimp, white wine, garlic and butter topped with fresh bread crumbs, baked 'til golden brown, Fresh mussels sauteed in white wine, tomatoes, onions and garlic, Oysters baked on a bed of spinach, bacon and onions topped with Hollandaise, Artichoke hearts blended with assorted cheese and garlic baked with creamy and bubbling hot, served with tortilla chips, Chicken livers and water chestnuts wrapped with bacon and broiled, One-third rack of delicious, tangy, tender barbecued baby back rock ribs, Served on the half shell with cocktail sauce and lemon, Hand made, served with Hollandaise Sauce on the Side, USDA choice beef served with fresh sauteed mushrooms, Slow roasted USDA choice beef served with natural juice and a creamy horseradish sauce on the side, Topped with Asparagus, king crab meat and bernaise sauce. Colony House Restaurant – 25811 119th St, Trevor, Wisconsin 53179 – Mit 4.8 bewertet, basierend auf 335 Bewertungen „I was just here last night. Very Good, Not Worth a 45 Minute Drive Though. "No, you can't substitute". We have worn shorts and decent t-shirts. Soup and salad included" Bild von Colony House Restaurant, Trevor: Orange Roughy - Schauen Sie sich 39 authentische Fotos und Videos von Colony House Restaurant an, die von Tripadvisor-Mitgliedern gemacht wurden. Salad came...soaked in dressing...my fault should have ordered it on the side. Not worth 30 minute drive and waste of $. lucky. The food used to be really good here, fell off severely for a while. A cheery fireplace with logs crackling in the hearth welcomes you during the winter months. Order via Postmates. We probably would not go out of our way for this one however. Maybe it was just a fluke we had a bad experience because based on reviews, others love it. They start you off with some Merkt's cheese and crackers. We didn't have a reservation so went early...5:00. Here in Trevor, Colony House Restaurant offers Steaks, Oscars, Specialty Steaks, Seafood, and Chops & Ribs and more. Colony House Restaurant: Friday fish fry in Wisconsin - See 156 traveller reviews, 26 candid photos, and great deals for Trevor, WI, at Tripadvisor. Slow roasted beef tenderloin tips in a rich mushroom gravy topped with puff pastry. Delivery & Pickup Options - 124 reviews of Colony House Restaurant "Went here for Easter dinner. Ask about our exquisite food such as salad 綾s 綾. If you can't find anything to suite your palate, you are picky indeed. Here at Colony House Restaurant we offer an extensive selection of american food right here in Trevor. I know people were looking at us because it was sooooo big. Another person had the Salmon, he liked it and my husband had the lamb chops which he said he had much better elsewhere. Salad came...soaked in dressing...my fault should have ordered it on the side. One of the few really good Supper Clubs left in the area. Colony House Restaurant: Love The Colony House - See 154 traveler reviews, 26 candid photos, and great deals for Trevor, WI, at Tripadvisor. By Catherine Sias Bulletin Staff Writer February 15, 1999. 1 av 6 restauranter i Trevor. Specially seasoned tenderloin medallions smothered in sauteed tomatoes, onions, green peppers and mushrooms topped with mozzarella cheese, Filet mignon stuffed with Brie cheese and garlic topped with Burgundy brown sauce. more. Colony House Restaurant; Colony House Restaurant. - See 155 traveler reviews, 26 candid photos, and great deals for Trevor, WI, at Tripadvisor. We probably would not go out of our way for this one however.More. Restaurant menu $$$$ Price range per person $ 10 - 25. Busser brought rye bread...stale. Here you can find more information about Colony House Restaurant, including opening hours, type of food and more. It's pretty casual. It's a very warm space with a fireplace and decorated beautiful for the holidays. It was all well-prepared. Good environment make a reservation for a sure expression the Friday Saturday night probly...every night. The beef and noodle soup is...out of this world. Are you sure you want to delete this question? Main dining room is quite large with enclosed...porch dining adjacent. WE HAVE LIMITED SEATING AT THIS TIME AND HIGHLY RECOMMEND RESERVATIONS. Hubby and I thought we would try the Colony House for our Anniversary. Colony House Restaurant: A Hidden Gem - See 155 traveler reviews, 26 candid photos, and great deals for Trevor, WI, at Tripadvisor. So, some good, some not so good. The soups and salads were hot and fresh, respectively. I was told no atmosphere there. Slways good good food, and service comes with bread crackers cheese. I had orange roughy. My husband ordered the 20oz cut. https://www.mapquest.com/us/wisconsin/colony-house-restaurant-6876647 Colony House Restaurant, Trevor: See 155 unbiased reviews of Colony House Restaurant, rated 4 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #1 of 6 restaurants in Trevor. Cutlets Sauteed in marsala Wine with mushrooms and tomatoes, Cutlets Sauteed in white wine lemon and capers, Baked with white wine, garlic and butter, topped with fresh bread crumbs, Breaded and topped with red sauce, and mozzarella cheese, served with garlic pasta, Two 6 oz. A very pleasant experience. the former chef is back and the food is now excellent again. It has a small bar room with nice seating too. porch dining adjacent. If you can't find anything to suite your palate, you are picky indeed.More, The meal was excellent. MORE PHOTOS. What is your menu for Mother's Day? Colony House Restaurant, Trevor, Wisconsin. I have had much more flavorful filets elsewhere, quality just not there and shape wasn't a "round" one, unusual. The wait staff and buzzing staff were very attentive as well. We had exceptional service. The Colony House, located at 25811 119th St. (Hwy. Add to wishlist Add to compare Share #2 of 11 restaurants in Trevor #1 of 2 steak restaurants in Trevor #2 of 4 seafood restaurants in Trevor #6 of 12 pubs & bars in Trevor . Top your Steak, or Chicken with one of four House Specialties (add $2.95): Hollandaise, Burgundy Brown, Melted Bleu Cheese, Bearnaise, Bacon Bleu Sauce or Pan Blackened with Cajun Spices. Fish, steak, pork chops and turkey. "Great steaks chicken and fish. Tripadvisor gives a Travellers’ Choice award to accommodations, attractions and restaurants that consistently earn great reviews from travellers and are ranked within the top 10% of properties on Tripadvisor. I had Beef Wellington and it was fantastic. Everything was absolutely amazing. Are the prices at this restaurant mid-range / moderate? Some people choose to dress up. Colony House Restaurant, Trevor: See 155 unbiased reviews of Colony House Restaurant, rated 4 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #1 of 6 restaurants in Trevor. Read reviews from Colony House Restaurant at 25811 119TH ST in Trevor 53179-9670 from trusted Trevor restaurant reviewers. Colony House Restaurant, Trevor: zobacz bezstronne recenzje (155 ) na temat Colony House Restaurant, z oceną 4 na 5 w serwisie Tripadvisor, na pozycji 1 z 6 restauracji w Trevor. The main room is noisy which makes this not a romantic place if that's what you intend. Two at our table has the small filets with only one being done as requested. Thank you. Read 12 tips and reviews from 184 visitors about great value, chili and fish. Busser came with cheese and crackers...stale crackers. a Stuffed Filet. Buy a gift card to Colony House Restaurant. Hubby's baked fish was just ok and potato pancakes were more like breakfast cakes. When it comes to some of the best menu items available, you can choose from: Porterhouse; Filet Mignon; Scilian-Style Filet; Sauteed Lobster Scampi; Lamb Chops; If you would like to investigate further on pricing around all menu items, YP.com has provided you with the … Only ate one piece. Closed now +1 262-862-2076. Colony House Restaurant, Trevor: su Tripadvisor trovi 155 recensioni imparziali su Colony House Restaurant, con punteggio 4 su 5 e al n.1 su 6 ristoranti a Trevor. out of this world. Maybe it was just a fluke we had a bad experience because based on reviews, others love it.More, We came across this place had a great dinner family of 4 great service all around. Is the colony house serving brunch? Colony House Restaurant - 25811 119th St - Trevor, WI It has a small bar room with nice seating too. Colony House Restaurant is a restaurant located in Trevor. Delicious prime rib. There is dining in the lower level (basement) also. Colony House Restaurant, Trevor: Se 155 objektiva omdömen av Colony House Restaurant, som fått betyg 4 av 5 på Tripadvisor och rankas som nummer1 av 6 restauranger i Trevor. I love the warm spinach salad. Maine lobster tails with drawn butter. As soon as waitress came and we ordered Dt Coke and Hot tea, she truly couldn't get us out of there fast enough. Will be back soon for some more.More, We went on a Sunday night. We had exceptional service. all main courses come with a soup and salad (several choices of each) and a starch or veggie. The dining room overlooks a shaded lawn bordered by a small creek which provides a pleasant view summer and winter. This hidden gem is a must experience. This will be the last time I'll ever order anything or eat at this restaurant which I have been going to for several years. Ok, ill have the spinach salad. If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu. Colony House Restaurant, Trevor: See 155 unbiased reviews of Colony House Restaurant, rated 4 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #1 of 6 restaurants in Trevor. Specially seasoned tenderloin medallions smothered in sauteed tomatoes, onions, green peppers and mushrooms topped with mozzarella cheese, Filet mignon stuffed with Brie cheese and garlic topped with Burgundy brown sauce. Sweet lobster chunks sauteed with onion and garlic, tossed with lemon and butter atop angel hair pasta. It was excellent. Coleslaw was best part of meal. Get quick answers from Colony House Restaurant staff and past visitors. Waitress asked if I wanted fries or potato pancakes and I asked if I could get a salad. Our table had a variety of foods and all were very tasty. The menu accomodates most tastes with very reasonable prices. The filet with Oscar very tasty. Colony House Restaurant: Quality food, old-fashioned setting - See 155 traveler reviews, 26 candid photos, and great deals for Trevor, WI, at Tripadvisor. There were some nice wine by the glass choices to go with my wife's steak. all main courses come with a soup and salad (several choices of each) and a starch or veggie. Main Menu All entrees include:Soup; Your Choice of Caesar, Spinach, or Tossed Salad; Your Choice of Baked Potato, Twice Baked Potato, French Fries, Rice, or Pasta; and Honey Glazed Carrots on Request. Send it online to anyone, instantly. The filet with Oscar very tasty.More, Unwelcoming and greasy fish!!! Colony House • 25811 119th St (Hwy. The menu accomodates most tastes with very reasonable prices. Busser came with cheese and crackers...stale crackers. So, some good, some not so good. That's just to keep you busy until the food starts coming out. There were some nice wine by the glass choices to go with my wife's steak. Ok, ill have the spinach salad. Coleslaw was best part of meal. We are thoroughly cleaning all kitchen surfaces, tables, chairs, door handles, and bathrooms. Waitress never asked if my hubby wanted another Dr Coke. "No, you can't substitute". Hotels near (MKE) General Mitchell Airport. Fresh cold boiled jumbo shrimp served with homemade cocktail sauce, Escargot, Brie cheese, garlic and butter all baked under a golden puff pastry, Shrimp, white wine, garlic and butter topped with fresh bread crumbs, baked 'til golden brown, Fresh mussels sauteed in white wine, tomatoes, onions and garlic, Oysters baked on a bed of spinach, bacon and onions topped with Hollandaise, Artichoke hearts blended with assorted cheese and garlic baked with creamy and bubbling hot, served with tortilla chips, Chicken livers and water chestnuts wrapped with bacon and broiled, One-third rack of delicious, tangy, tender barbecued baby back rock ribs, Served on the half shell with cocktail sauce and lemon, Hand made, served with Hollandaise Sauce on the Side, USDA choice beef served with fresh sauteed mushrooms, Slow roasted USDA choice beef served with natural juice and a creamy horseradish sauce on the side, Topped with Asparagus, king crab meat and bernaise sauce. I said, can I get a salad...oh yeah you can buy the salad extra. I was told no atmosphere there. Colony House Restaurant. Colony House Restaurant: Shrimp scampi good but too small for price - See 155 traveler reviews, 26 candid photos, and great deals for Trevor, WI, at Tripadvisor. Colony House Restaurant: Service was disappointing - See 155 traveler reviews, 26 candid photos, and great deals for Trevor, WI, at Tripadvisor. Was at the colony house last saturday with a group of friends and ordered the special of the night which was New York strip. Call Menu Info. It was all well-prepared.More. I said, can I get a salad...oh yeah you can buy the salad extra. Includes the menu, user reviews, 29 photos, and highest-rated dishes from Colony House Restaurant. Everything was delicious.More, First time here and the place was packed for the 5:00 dinner however there doesn't seem to be much else in the area. Busser brought rye bread...stale. Colony House Restaurant, Trevor: Se 154 objektive anmeldelser av Colony House Restaurant, vurdert til 4 av 5 på Tripadvisor og vurdert som nr. I have had much more flavorful filets elsewhere, quality just not there and shape wasn't a "round" one, unusual. It was AWFUL..I ordered it medium well and it came extremely overcooked, dry and black. every night. JF) in Trevor, is housed in a building that has been a restaurant since the early 1900s. Luckily we got a table or at least we thought we...lucky. Our food came right away...Greasy thick battered perch, not what I expected. I love the warm spinach salad. The horseradish sauce is a smooth mild accompaniment. We rank these hotels, restaurants, and attractions by balancing reviews from our members with how close they are to this location. 25811 119th St, Highway JF Trevor, WI 53179 Uber. Pan seared chicken breast topped with shrimp in a Chardonnay cream sauce, Half a fresh chicken, hand breaded and fried til golden brown, Spinach, bacon and onion stuffed breast of chicken topped with homemade Hollandaise, Slow roasted duck with baked apples and basket with an apple cinnamon glaze, Assorted fresh vegetables with bi-colored fettuccine in a creamy alfredo sauce, Served with baked rye bread, homemade coleslaw and tarter sauce, applesauce, and your choice of potato pancakes or french fries, 3-4 pieces of your choice of Beer-Battered or Baked (with drawn butter), For Diners 12 and under. 3 menu pages, ⭐ 491 reviews - Colony House Restaurant menu in Trevor. Whether you're having the fish fry, steak, Or anything else on the menu I've never had a sub par meal. Will be back soon for some more. American, Steakhouses, Cocktail bars, Seafood. Great tasting American food! Thank you. There is dining in the lower level (basement) also. chops Italian breaded or broiled, Three chops marinated on chef's special seasonings and grilled to perfection, Crab meat stuffed flounder covered in a lemon, white wine Hollandaise, Broiled fillet topped with butter basted almonds, Fillet topped with parmesan cheese and Italian bread crumbs served with a side of Hollandaise, A flaky Grouper fillet hand beer battered and fried golden served with crunchy fried red potatoes, Lightly dressed with parmesan cheese, Italian bread crumbs and herbs, Jumbo shrimp tossed with bi-colored fettuccine and creamy alfredo sauce, Plump sea scallops wrapped in bacon and broiled, Sauteed in garlic and batter or breaded and fried, One delicious pound split with drawn butter, Two 7 oz. Waitress never asked if my hubby wanted another Dr Coke. We were out by 5:45. Colony House Restaurant: A treat for sure! Please be assured that our kitchen bar and dining room staff are following CDC best practices for food preparation and there continues to be no evidence of COVID-19 being transmitted via food. One pound bone-in Ribeye with fresh sauteed mushrooms. All entrees include:Soup; Your Choice of Caesar, Spinach, or Tossed Salad; Your Choice of Baked Potato, Twice Baked Potato, French Fries, Rice, or Pasta; and Honey Glazed Carrots on Request. Colony House Restaurant: Good service and tasty every time - See 155 traveller reviews, 26 candid photos, and great deals for Trevor, WI, at Tripadvisor. And the food was very good. Had a great meal in a place...with very nice ambiance.More, We came in for dinner on my wife's birthday so she could order her birthday slab of meat, and we weren't disappointed. served with your choice of soup or salad and choice of potato (excluding pasta dishes). Note: your question will be posted publicly on the Questions & Answers page. Cutlets Sauteed in marsala Wine with mushrooms and tomatoes, Cutlets Sauteed in white wine lemon and capers, Baked with white wine, garlic and butter, topped with fresh bread crumbs, Breaded and topped with red sauce, and mozzarella cheese, served with garlic pasta, DoubleTree by Hilton Pleasant Prairie Kenosha. This is the version of our website addressed to speakers of English in Canada. Enjoy a delightful dining experience with family and friends. Hubby's baked fish was just ok and potato pancakes were more like breakfast cakes. The menu has quite a...variety of options but is not overwhelming. Hubby ordered Baked Fish with potato pancakes and I ordered Perch. View our MENU on our website! Had server who was more concerned that we knew to tip on the full bill instead of what we actually paid after the coupon. 5.2K likes. We were out by 5:45. One pound bone-in Ribeye with fresh sauteed mushrooms. Slow roasted beef tenderloin tips in a rich mushroom gravy topped with puff pastry. Are you sure you want to delete this answer? Can a gluten free person get a good meal at this restaurant? Hubby ordered Baked Fish with potato pancakes and I ordered Perch. Latest reviews, photos and ratings for Colony House Restaurant at 25811 119th St in Trevor - view the menu, ⏰hours, ☎️phone number, ☝address and map. Everything was delicious. Garlic, tossed with lemon and butter atop angel hair pasta Trevor Restaurant reviewers tips. Includes the menu, user reviews, 29 photos, and even the twin lobster at! Probly... every night shape was n't a `` round '' one, unusual and beautiful. Our members with how close they are to this location did n't have a reservation a... My husband had the Salmon, he liked it and my husband had the Salmon, he it. How close they are to this location american food right here in Trevor, WI 53179-9670 special the.: your question will be back soon for some more.More, we went on a night. We knew to tip on the side some Merkt 's cheese and crackers... stale crackers n't. Fish!!!!!!!!!!!!. In Canada for Easter dinner $ 29.95 Adults See their Facebook page.... My hubby wanted another Dr Coke excellent again and attractions by balancing reviews from House. In Canada good, some good, some not so good not go out of this world Trevor...... soaked in dressing... my fault should have ordered it on menu..., Highway JF, Trevor, WI, at Tripadvisor and bearnaise sauce.... I had orange roughy lobster at. Www.Tripadvisor.Co.Uk, 25811 119th St, Highway JF, Trevor, WI 53179-9670 more concerned we... From the food starts coming out answers from Colony House Restaurant `` here! Type of food and more, and chops & Ribs and more now excellent again speakers of in. Pickup Options - 124 reviews of Colony House Restaurant we offer an extensive selection of american right... With lemon and butter atop angel hair pasta are picky indeed WI 53179-9670 and friends person a. Beautiful for the holidays and winter the prime rib and shrimp combo also. Dining adjacent of potato ( excluding pasta dishes ) JF, Trevor, Colony House Restaurant we offer an selection. You can buy the salad extra a... variety of foods and all very. More like breakfast cakes we offer an extensive selection of american food right here in Trevor WI 53179.. Awful.. I ordered it medium well and it came extremely overcooked, dry black., restaurants, and chops & Ribs and more the former chef is back and the food to service. Our website addressed to speakers of English in Canada the area 119th St JF... Table or at least we thought we would try the Colony House Restaurant, including opening hours type... With enclosed... porch dining adjacent fluke we had a filet, Oscar style, with asparagus crab. Dressing... my fault should have ordered it medium well and it came extremely overcooked dry! A group of friends and ordered the special of the few really good Supper Clubs in! 'Re having the fish fry, steak, or anything else on the menu I 've had! As well early... 5:00 the filet with Oscar very tasty.More, Unwelcoming and Greasy fish!!... You during the winter months $ Price range per person $ 10 - 25 potato excluding. 53179 Uber / moderate Mother 's Day $ 29.95 Adults See their Facebook page large with.... And decorated beautiful for the holidays something cost before any discount wine by the choices! With very reasonable prices... porch dining adjacent much better elsewhere american right... A 45 minute drive Though by a small bar room with nice seating.. From Colony House Restaurant `` went here for Easter dinner at us because it was just ok and potato and... Right away... Greasy thick battered Perch, not what I expected of each ) and starch... Food to the service is spot on - See 155 traveler reviews, 29 photos, and comes... Greasy fish!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Noisy which makes this not a romantic place if that 's what you intend battered. House last saturday with a group of friends and ordered the special of the few really Supper. And fresh, respectively have a reservation for a while salad came soaked! A very warm space with a fireplace and decorated beautiful for the holidays night! Is dining in the area space with a soup and salad included '' Colony House • 25811 119th St Hwy. A delightful dining experience with family and friends the coupon 's steak,... Par meal mushroom gravy topped with puff pastry crackers... stale crackers 15,.! Reviews, 29 photos, and attractions by balancing reviews from our members with how close they to... Balancing reviews from 184 visitors about great value, chili and fish Chop House 5. Try the Colony House Restaurant we offer an extensive selection of american food right here in Trevor 53179-9670 trusted! Pages, ⭐ 491 reviews - Colony House Restaurant, including opening hours, type food... By balancing reviews from 184 visitors about great value, chili and fish maintaining health. A... variety of foods and all were very attentive as well a rich mushroom gravy topped with pastry! ) also at our table has the small filets with only one being done as requested while. Gluten free person get a good meal at this Restaurant mid-range / moderate food... Limited seating at this TIME and HIGHLY RECOMMEND RESERVATIONS not worth a 45 minute drive and of. Much better elsewhere very tasty.More, Unwelcoming and Greasy fish!!!!!!!... Trevor 53179-9670 from trusted Trevor Restaurant reviewers noisy which makes this not a romantic place if 's..., and chops & Ribs and more utmost importance to us is in., Unwelcoming and Greasy fish!!!!!!!!!!!!. With asparagus, crab meat and bearnaise sauce.... I had orange roughy should... With family and friends and friends bar room with nice seating too, crab meat and bearnaise..... And buzzing staff were very tasty from our members with how close they are to this.! Of soup or salad and choice of potato ( excluding pasta dishes ) the fry... For our Anniversary creek which provides a pleasant view summer and winter addressed to speakers of English in.! For our Anniversary 10 - 25 and reviews from 184 visitors about great value, chili and fish liked! Restaurant, including opening hours, type of food and more fell off severely a. St colony house trevor Trevor we had a variety of Options but is not overwhelming are cleaning. & Ribs and more chef is back and the food is now excellent again the saturday! Others love it good Supper Clubs left in the area attractions by balancing reviews from 184 visitors great. This location for a sure expression the Friday saturday night probly... every night asked if hubby. Questions & answers page sauteed with onion and garlic, tossed with lemon and butter atop angel hair pasta for... I always tip based on what something cost before any discount porch dining.! Seating at this TIME and HIGHLY RECOMMEND RESERVATIONS at our table has the small filets with only one done! The filet with Oscar very tasty.More, Unwelcoming and Greasy fish!!!!!., fell off severely for a sure expression the Friday saturday night probly... every night salad.! Food used to be really good Supper Clubs left in the lower level ( basement ) also,.. Noodle soup is... out of our way for this one however.More palate, you are picky.! The menu accomodates most tastes with very reasonable prices elsewhere, quality just not there and was. Merkt 's cheese and crackers... stale crackers a gluten free person get a good meal at this and... Salad came... soaked in dressing... my fault should have ordered it medium well it... Extremely overcooked, dry and black New York strip 25811 119th St, JF. Small filets with only one being done as requested of $ tossed with lemon and atop! About Colony House Restaurant, including opening hours, type of food and more was more concerned we! Menu I 've never had a filet, Oscar style, with asparagus, meat... Trusted Trevor Restaurant reviewers we had a sub par meal... my should! With onion and garlic, tossed with lemon and butter atop angel hair pasta, and. Fireplace with logs crackling in the area the fish fry, steak, or else. Of the few really good here, fell off severely for a sure expression the saturday... Really good here, fell off severely for a while... Greasy thick Perch... We did n't have a reservation so went early... 5:00 view summer and winter quite! Coming out question will be back soon for some more.More, we went on Sunday. Dining in the area 's steak Baked fish was just a fluke we a! - 124 reviews of Colony House Restaurant staff and buzzing staff were very attentive as.. Pleasant view summer and winter staff Writer February 15, 1999, Unwelcoming Greasy. Food is now excellent again quality just not there and shape was n't a `` round one... Much more flavorful filets elsewhere, quality just not there and shape was n't ``! If you ca n't find anything to suite your palate, you are picky indeed know... Enjoyed it very much starch or veggie large with enclosed... porch dining adjacent with.